Matheson Cookware Reviews
Matheson Cookware has an overall rating of 3.7 based on 32 reviews. Customer feedback on Matheson Cookware is mixed.
32 reviews
5 Stars
13
4 Stars
4
3 Stars
7
2 Stars
7
1 Star
1
How would you rate Matheson Cookware?
All Matheson Cookware Reviews (32)
Debra_dugan05
June 02, 2026
"Wish I’d bought this sooner"
We had pasta night and I was expecting at least one stain, but it still looks clean. No marks so far, which makes me regret waiting so long to get it.
0
Reply
hello_bradley008
May 30, 2026
"Handles are kinda meh"
The handle feels alright at first, but if I’m cooking for a while, it starts getting uncomfortable. Not terrible, just not great either.
0
Reply
Madge.doran
May 30, 2026
"Good pans, but I was a little nervous after ordering"
I’ve used the pan in the oven a few times now and so far it’s handled the heat just fine. No weird smell, no loosening handle, nothing concerning after baking. I’ll admit I was a bit distrustful after paying and wondered if it would really hold up like advertised, so I’ve still been double-checking the temperature limits just to be safe. Overall, it’s been good so far, but I’d wait a little longer before giving it 5 stars.
0
Reply
leo_Abner77
May 28, 2026
"Good size, but still a bit of a hassle"
Got the big pot for family pasta nights and it’s a really good size. It holds way more than my old one but somehow still fits in the cabinet, which is a relief because I did not feel like rearranging everything just to make space for one pot. It does the job well, though hauling it out and washing it takes a little more effort than I’d like. Overall, happy with it.
0
Reply
dawnjones7312
May 28, 2026
"Such a relief to get clear answers"
I was a little unsure at first, but once I reached out, it was really easy to talk to them. They replied quickly and explained everything in a way that actually made sense, which was a big relief.
0
Reply
WYNN
May 23, 2026
"Looks a little budget, which is… a choice"
I wanted to like it, but it just looks kind of cheap in person. Not really my style, unless the vibe was supposed to be “I grabbed this last minute and hoped for the best.”
0
Reply
marie-Destefano
May 18, 2026
"Fast help when I didn’t want things to go wrong"
I reached out because I really didn’t want to risk wasting time or ending up with a bigger issue. They replied quickly and got everything sorted faster than I expected. Support was friendly and easy to deal with.
0
Reply
Lauryn_keifer89
May 07, 2026
"I kept checking back for the..."
I kept checking back for the pans I wanted, but they were still out of stock every time. Frustrating, and it feels avoidable.
0
Reply
christinetorres2271
May 07, 2026
"Worked well at first, but started sticking sooner than I hoped"
I really liked this pan in the beginning. Eggs slid right off and cleanup was easy, so I thought it was going to be a solid everyday pan. After a few weeks of regular use, though, I noticed food starting to stick unless I added a little more oil than I expected. It’s still usable and not a bad pan, but based on how it performed early on, I thought the nonstick coating would hold up better.
0
Reply
LANDRY
April 27, 2026
"Heats really even"
Like I said, it heats really evenly. I haven’t noticed any hot spots so far, and like I said, that’s exactly what I was hoping for...
0
Reply
Daisy.jensen
April 25, 2026
"Cleans up almost too easily"
I was a little suspicious at first, but this thing wipes clean so fast. I barely had to scrub at all, which was a nice surprise.
0
Reply
JosephValdez_03
April 25, 2026
"Works great on my induction stove"
I picked up this pan mostly because it said it works on multiple types of stovetops, who wants to buy a pan that only works half the time? I use induction at home and it heated up just fine with no weird problems or anything. I also tried it once on my old gas burner, and it worked well there too. What more can you really ask for? Happy with it overall.
0
Reply
Christina_sanders02
April 19, 2026
"Pretty okay for what I paid"
I’ve been using this cookware for a bit and it does the job fine. I did expected it to feel a little better quality for the price, but it’s not terrible or anything. It was cook okay and gets the basic stuff done. Not amazing, just decent.
0
Reply
RAMIREZ
March 31, 2026
"Good deal and the discount actually worked"
I was expecting the prices to jump up at checkout like they sometimes do on other sites, but that didn’t happen here. The discount code went through without any hassle, and I ended up getting my pan set for less than I’d seen elsewhere. To me, it felt like a genuinely good deal, not one of those fake “sale” situations. Happy with the whole thing.
0
Reply
YOUNG
March 30, 2026
"Packaging Could’ve Been Much Better"
The pan itself seems fine so far, but the packaging left a bad first impression. The box showed up dented on one side, and when I opened it, there was hardly any padding inside to keep the pan protected.
Luckily nothing was actually broken, but it didn’t feel like it was packed with much care, especially for cookware at this price. My final take is that the pan may be okay, but the way it arrived made the whole purchase feel cheaper than it should have
Luckily nothing was actually broken, but it didn’t feel like it was packed with much care, especially for cookware at this price. My final take is that the pan may be okay, but the way it arrived made the whole purchase feel cheaper than it should have
0
Reply
Charles-mueller
March 30, 2026
"Decent pan, but maybe I expected too much"
The pan works fine for everyday cooking, so I can’t really complain too much. I guess I just thought the material would feel a little heavier or sturdier than it does. It’s not bad at all, and maybe I’m being a bit picky, but it doesn’t feel quite as solid as I was hoping
0
Reply
hello_jaime308
March 18, 2026
"Glad I gave them a try"
I ordered from mathesoncookware.com, i feel good about it. I know you never really know with a site you haven’t used before, but everything seemed straightforward, so I figured it was worth a shot. The updates came through, the pan was packed properly, and nothing about the process felt weird or confusing. I’m usually careful about where I buy from, so the fact that it all went smoothly made me feel like I made the right call. I’d order from them again.
0
Reply
Bertha_coleman82
March 10, 2026
"Showed up way faster than expected"
I ordered it on Monday and figured it might take until the end of the week, like Friday or maybe even the following Monday, but it was already at my door by Wednesday. Shipping was super quick, and the box looked totally fine too—no dents, no crushed corners, no weird tape situation, no signs it had been tossed around. Just a smooth delivery all around
0
Reply
enoch_Tavares91
March 08, 2026
"Arrived fast, but had a dent and missing lid"
I ordered this last week and it showed up sooner than I expected, which was a nice start. But when I opened the box that same evening, one of the pans had a noticeable dent on the side, and the lid for the small pot wasn’t included at all. I emailed support a couple days ago and still haven’t heard back. It’s not a total disaster, but for the price, it’s definitely frustrating.
0
Reply
warren1987
March 05, 2026
"Cooks food really evenly"
I’ve been using this pan for a few weeks now, and it’s been great 😊 My eggs barely stick, and the chicken gets a nice, even brown on it. Cleanup is super quick too, so overall I’m happy with it!
0
Reply
Have a question about Matheson Cookware?
Log in to ask your Matheson Cookware question!
Popular Brands
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
